Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

How to keep the Cessna 170 flying and airworthy.

Moderators: GAHorn, Karl Towle, Bruce Fenstermacher

User avatar
cessna170bdriver
Posts: 4059
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:13 pm

Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by cessna170bdriver »

During 2597C’s annual we found two exterior rivet heads missing on the left lower radius of the aft fuselage where the elevator bellcrank bulkhead is located. From the outside, the shanks appeared to still be there, but one had paint on it, so it had been this way for quite some time? 8O
E73B1C42-D5C6-4868-AC5F-ACAA89BDBE4B.jpeg

A look on the inside with a borescope revealed that particular portion of the bulkhead flange to have no rivets in the holes and the flange not even seated on the skin, but get this: the two rivets with missing heads had partially formed shop heads UNDER the flange. 8O 8O .
A66D705B-E5B5-4634-B6C6-4AA37E4FF83A.jpeg
Closer inspection shows an area where about a dozen rivets are not adequately holding the bulkhead flange (the area circled in magenta in the IPC photo).
3E0EE3D6-52D9-4233-8CAD-9CF5850175FD.jpeg
.
90398EEA-EE42-4783-B2C3-BA0EE9F72E90.jpeg
3985CB69-C27C-4287-8524-2D4EECC188E1.jpeg
Seeing as how most of the rivets in this bulkhead are 5/32, and the same rivets in my ‘55 170B are 1/8, I assume this bulkhead has been either replaced or re-riveted sometime in the past, though I haven’t yet searched the logs to see when or by whom.

An AI who lives a few doors down from me is helping us with correcting this issue, and so far we’ve been able to drill out the the shanks of the two headless rivets, then remove the tails with a chip chaser, working through the inspection hole on top of the fuselage to the right of the vertical stabilizer. We thought it would be a good idea to get these two rivets replaced before removing existing rivets on up the side. We’ve been able to pull that lowest two-hole section of bulkhead flange against the skin with wingnut clecos, but since these rivets are in the lower left radius of the fuselage skins, in the tight area just to the left of the bellcrank bracket, we haven’t been able get a bucking bar located adequately, at least by the Braille method through that same inspection hole.

We’ve removed the baggage bulkhead cover and it looks like we might be able to get a better shot at it by going down the tailcone, once we get adequate support and padding back there to lay on. Does anyone who has done this before have any tips to offer regarding access, bucking bars, etc? We’ve thought about using cherrymaxes for these two hardest to reach rivets, but our AI is unable to find any guidance that says they can be used in this area.
Miles

“I envy no man that knows more than myself, but pity them that know less.”
— Thomas Browne
User avatar
GAHorn
Posts: 20967
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2002 8:45 pm

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by GAHorn »

Miles, my EAA guide states “ Cherry rivets are another type of blind rivet. The friction Cherry rivet is a self-plugging blind rivet that has a hollow rivet and a stem, much like a pop rivet. They are available with a countersunk head or a universal head. The designation for a countersunk is CR9162 and the universal head is CR9163. The strength of this type Cherry rivet is less than the bulbed type that will be subsequently discussed. You cannot replace a solid shank rivet with the same size of this type rivet. You must use 1/32 inch diameter larger to obtain the necessary strength. A special tool is required to pull these rivets.

Cherrylock and Cherrymax rivets are suitable replacements for the same size solid shank rivet. ”

I’m not an expert on this... but your AI might be interested in this.
'53 B-model N146YS SN:25713
50th Anniversary of Flight Model. Winner-Best Original 170B, 100th Anniversary of Flight Convention.
An originality nut (mostly) for the right reasons. ;)
User avatar
cessna170bdriver
Posts: 4059
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:13 pm

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by cessna170bdriver »

GAHorn wrote:Miles, my EAA guide states “ Cherry rivets are another type of blind rivet. The friction Cherry rivet is a self-plugging blind rivet that has a hollow rivet and a stem, much like a pop rivet. They are available with a countersunk head or a universal head. The designation for a countersunk is CR9162 and the universal head is CR9163. The strength of this type Cherry rivet is less than the bulbed type that will be subsequently discussed. You cannot replace a solid shank rivet with the same size of this type rivet. You must use 1/32 inch diameter larger to obtain the necessary strength. A special tool is required to pull these rivets.

Cherrylock and Cherrymax rivets are suitable replacements for the same size solid shank rivet. ”

I’m not an expert on this... but your AI might be interested in this.
Thank you George. We are thinking of Cherrymax, not Cherry, though in our case the holes are already oversized by 1/32. Our AI is a retired Delta Airlines mechanic, so he probably won’t put much stock in an EAA guide, but would be more likely to follow guidance from the FAA or Cessna.
Miles

“I envy no man that knows more than myself, but pity them that know less.”
— Thomas Browne
User avatar
n2582d
Posts: 2808
Joined: Mon Apr 29, 2002 4:58 am

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by n2582d »

AC43.13-1B paragraph 4-57, f, (2) says in bold and underlined font:
Screen Shot 2020-12-26 at 8.05.37 PM.png
Screen Shot 2020-12-26 at 8.05.37 PM.png (21.05 KiB) Viewed 4450 times
Cessna's Structural Repair Manual has a table listing approved replacement fasteners in Chapter 51 (51-40-00 pg. 3). This manual doesn’t specifically apply to the C-170 but I think it’s as close to an official Cessna source as you’re going to find. For what it's worth NAS 1398 rivets cross to Cherrylock CR 2263, NAS 1738 cross to Cherrylock CR 2249, and NAS 9301 cross to CherryMax CR3213 rivets.
Last edited by n2582d on Sun Dec 27, 2020 2:50 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Gary
User avatar
c170b53
Posts: 2527
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 8:01 pm

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by c170b53 »

The fingers on that bulkhead are light and they would have to be held against the structure to allow the rivet to be set otherwise they (fingers) will pull away and the rivet will form to tails, one between the skins the other on the outside. Done it many times often when I thought the parts were held tightly together. Out comes the drill, to drill out the rivet and re-do. So like you say Miles access is not great which made it hard to keep the work together. You’ve drill them out and used power clecos to hold the materials together, perfect. You should be able to do the same elsewhere. Larger rivets means a bigger bar which I guess is working against you now as is eroded edge distance. If the rivet is wobbly you could go oversize cherry max, you’ve correctly identified the problem, working through that hole means one hand when you need two. I’ve crawled up to that bulkhead many times only issue is the blood flow to the brain and working around the pull handles.
Jim McIntosh..
1953 C170B S/N 25656
02 K1200RS
User avatar
n2582d
Posts: 2808
Joined: Mon Apr 29, 2002 4:58 am

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by n2582d »

Miles, Building an RV you’ve certainly pounded a lot more rivets than I ever have so I’m guessing you’re familiar with the following tip. An old time sheet metal guy at MAF taught me to use a piece of sponge or foam, with a small hole in the center, between the bucking bar and sheet metal you’re riveting to help clamp the sheets together. Just need it there for the first short drive.
Gary
User avatar
cessna170bdriver
Posts: 4059
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:13 pm

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by cessna170bdriver »

n2582d wrote:Miles, Building an RV you’ve certainly pounded a lot more rivets than I ever have so I’m guessing you’re familiar with the following tip. An old time sheet metal guy at MAF taught me to use a piece of sponge or foam, with a small hole in the center, between the bucking bar and sheet metal you’re riveting to help clamp the sheets together. Just need it there for the first short drive.
The clecos seem to be pulling the flange into place adequately; the bigger problem is access to buck the rivets. On the RV, when a flange won’t pull down with adjacent clecos, I use an o-ring over the rivet shank for the first few hits. Probably 3/4 of the nearly 12,000 rivets in my RV so far I’ve shot with a gun and bucking bar, but the vast majority of those are short #3s, with the build order planned for good access. Buckling #5s in the interior of an otherwise completely assembled airplane is a whole ‘nuther story.
Miles

“I envy no man that knows more than myself, but pity them that know less.”
— Thomas Browne
User avatar
n2582d
Posts: 2808
Joined: Mon Apr 29, 2002 4:58 am

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by n2582d »

cessna170bdriver wrote:[... the bigger problem is access to buck the rivets. ...
Too bad STC # SA000858DE, the inspection panel kit from Aeropod, doesn't include the 170 as the fuselage is basically the same as the early 180.

The FedEx ramp agent in Grand Rapids is a skinny kid working on his A&P. I think he could use some valuable experience with a bucking bar in a tailcone. Charge him $25/hr. for the experience! :lol:
Gary
User avatar
170C
Posts: 3182
Joined: Tue May 06, 2003 11:59 am

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by 170C »

Just a comment Miles. When I installed my Tail Pull Handles, I did not want to lay on the control cables. I didn't have any 4-6 inch foam so I spent more time making wooden pieces from 2x4's that were contoured to the bottom of the aft fuselage with cut outs for the cables than it took to install the handles. Then I could lay a piece of plywood on top of the "pieces" so I could lay on them and not put any pressure/strain on the cables. It was my job to crawl into the tail cone while my IA was on the outside. Also used my Tail Wheel lift to raise the tail up so I wasn't going downhill and more importantly not having to crawl backward up hill. Probably much overkill. Still have the pieces excluding the plywood. Probably never need them again, but if so I don't have to build again. Good luck with the riveting project.
OLE POKEY
170C
Director:
2012-2018
User avatar
DaveF
Posts: 1516
Joined: Sat Nov 03, 2007 1:44 am

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by DaveF »

Oh, ok, I've got it now ... this is your *other* 170. I couldn't understand how this could have gone unnoticed in the Great Rebuilding, or how your new paint could be so grimy already.
User avatar
cessna170bdriver
Posts: 4059
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:13 pm

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by cessna170bdriver »

We made a fair amount progress yesterday. We were able to put heavy cardboard down inside the belly, and surprisingly enough I was able to wiggle my bulk back far enough to get my head and shoulders into that last open bay and put eyes and hands directly on the elevator bellcrank bulkhead. After going through a box full of bucking bars I found an angled one that, with a minor adjustment, fit in the angle between the bellcrank bracket and the radius of the bottom skin.
8C89C2A0-890F-444C-B6D1-AFF9084138C2.jpeg
Since the hole was up to a #21 for a 5/32 rivet I didn’t think that bar was heavy enough, so I taped my nearly 2-lb tungsten bar (not much bigger than a pack of chewing gum) to the side of it for more mass. It isn’t perfect, but passable. For the other hole in that segment of the flange, I found that with the screw removed and in that confined space, I couldn’t generate enough force to push he flange flush to the skin, but I did find that I could use a small prybar and a 2x4 block to pry it down flush. There being no way to also get a bucking bar in there, our AI decided that we could install a Cherry Max there, and could reference Cessna’s Structural Repair Manual for approval.
C68AB616-5AAB-468C-AFF2-8B7756369EE2.jpeg
Working up the side, there was a 5-hole flange not held flush to the skin. We drilled out the end rivets and used #6 screws to pull the flange flush, then replaced the center three with #4 AD rivets which bucked nicely with just my tungsten bar. Again, the ends can’t be held flush without the screws, so we’re also going to use Cherry Max rivets there also.
CDB92192-A66F-4B51-BF84-68D1A4408C6B.jpeg
Our next scheduled workday is Thursday, and hopefully we can get this job wrapped up.
Miles

“I envy no man that knows more than myself, but pity them that know less.”
— Thomas Browne
User avatar
gobrien
Posts: 113
Joined: Sun May 19, 2019 11:36 am

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by gobrien »

Hey Miles,

Is it not possible to leave the screws in as the permanent fixture?

Gareth.
1948 170 Project (N4180V) now EI-AEN SN:18513 - Dublin, Ireland
https://www.taildragger.eu/
User avatar
GAHorn
Posts: 20967
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2002 8:45 pm

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by GAHorn »

gobrien wrote:Hey Miles,

Is it not possible to leave the screws in as the permanent fixture?

Gareth.
Doubtless to his great relief... :roll: .... I’m not Miles... but will offer that a screw (or any other threaded fastener) would/must be installed in a reamed-to-fit hole to be effective to work with other fasteners. Otherwise only one/or few fasteners would be supporting the load instead of sharing the load among all.

A major advantage of rivets is that they expand to fill the hole tightly in addition to clamping, whereas a threaded fastener relies chiefly upon friction/clamping to attain strength. So, I will guess that the answer provided by more competent folks than I will suggest that, while you could leave the screw in-situ... it would not provide the same strength as the “teamwork” of all riveted would. Further, while there are some exceptions, most screws are “all-thread” design....without shank.... therefore would not provide a tight shear fitment. (It would be poor form and not likely allowed in a certificated airframe without proper reaming.)
'53 B-model N146YS SN:25713
50th Anniversary of Flight Model. Winner-Best Original 170B, 100th Anniversary of Flight Convention.
An originality nut (mostly) for the right reasons. ;)
User avatar
cessna170bdriver
Posts: 4059
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:13 pm

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by cessna170bdriver »

George is correct; riveted joints are designed so that every rivet shares the shear load on the joint. To do that, each rivet swells up to completely fill the hole when it’s installed. If a screw or bolt is installed, or a rivet is installed improperly and doesn’t completely fill the hole, the shear load it should have handled is passed on to the others.
Miles

“I envy no man that knows more than myself, but pity them that know less.”
— Thomas Browne
User avatar
gobrien
Posts: 113
Joined: Sun May 19, 2019 11:36 am

Re: Re-riveting the Elevator Bellcrank Bulkhead

Post by gobrien »

I was thinking of something like https://www.aircraftspruce.com/catalog/ ... 9-1-05.php suitably sized, this specific one is likely too big. This is a pan-head screw with a shank (used for seat belt harness attachment). While I understand that the rivet fills the hole my concern is that the parts are pulling apart, and the previous attempt resulted in a shop head forming between the parts which I've had happen. If you can get the holes close to appropriately reamed, the clamping action of the screw as it is driven closed will tend to pull the parts together, this would seem a better option to riveting those 2 holes, even with blind rivets.

This may not be permitted with a certified plane; which was more where I was headed. How much discretion does one have to do such things?
1948 170 Project (N4180V) now EI-AEN SN:18513 - Dublin, Ireland
https://www.taildragger.eu/
Post Reply