I thought I was overweight [aircraft]

A place to relax and discuss flying topics.

Moderators: GAHorn, Karl Towle, Bruce Fenstermacher

Post Reply
User avatar
ghostflyer
Posts: 1392
Joined: Mon Apr 21, 2008 3:06 am

I thought I was overweight [aircraft]

Post by ghostflyer »

There has been a mix up in the kilograms and pounds [weight ] with my aircraft from the very first day I have first put it on the register. I was very recently looking at a friends 170b and he has a decal in his cargo area stating a limit of 120 lbs . I thought this was a little high as mine states 55 lbs/25 kilos on its decal. Did a check on the type certificate and it’s 120lbs. My decal was manufactured by a small company here in Australia. I had them make a heap of decals up for my aircraft . We use kilograms ,kilometres etc in this country . It seems that somebody was trying to recalculate the lbs to kilos and mixed Up every thing . 120lbs is equals 55kilos . But then they put the lbs in place of the kilos .
They had a copy of the type certificate as a reference and areas high lighted for reproducing. It’s some thing I have never though about and only took at face value . So when I have though I was approaching being over weight ,I have been well under and not know it. Just checked my weight and balance sheet [load data sheet] and it’s states 55lbs/25kilos.
User avatar
GAHorn
Posts: 20989
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2002 8:45 pm

Re: I thought I was overweight [aircraft]

Post by GAHorn »

It was with some degree of embarrassment when I realized what I’d done during the fly-out at the Wilmington convention in 2003. I was the “lead” aircraft of a 5-plane gaggle to take-off together from ILM to the Kill Devil Hills event, and for some reason I was “elected” to be the lead aircraft... perhaps because the rest of the gaggle was under the mis-impression I was paid at my regular job as a pilot so therefore I must be the “professional” in the group...therefore should lead. Not sure why they leapt to that deduction but their error was quickly proven ,,,and soon over-shadowed by my own.

I had planned Jamie and I to be alone in our B-model and we had been topped off with fuel two days earlier when we arrived in order to avoid any delays at the end of convention. I didn’t consider this two days later when Ol’ Gar (flyguy) approached me and asked if he and Deanna could ride-along on the flight up the Cape to the fly-out. So, as all 5 of us taxied into position and were cleared for take-off you might imagine my horror as I suddenly became aware of the lack of acceleration on that near 100-degree day.

To top that off, the No. 2 aircraft in the gaggle was Harold Holiman in his C-180... who was airborne in the first 500 feet... then the other three 170s who were airborne soon-after... while their brain-dead “leader” was still solidly on the pavement 1500-feet later and trying to accelerate.

The full fuel, 500 lbs of Ol’Gar and me sitting in front of another 250+ (To be kind to the ladies) sitting in the back-seats (not to mention the 40 lbs of survival gear and life-vests I always carried in the baggage on long trips) placed us at least 300 lbs over gross, and the only reason ol’ 146YS with it’s cruise-pitched-prop flew at-all that day was curvature-of-the-earth. .
Our departure instructions were to turn-right immediately after takeoff to a 050 heading, but while trying to gain sufficient speed to enable a climb out of ground-effect and with the stall warning occasionally squeaking I dared not initiate a turn. A mile off the departure end I called departure and got chewed-out for not being on assigned heading and I could only imagine what my followers were thinking of their elected-leader as we were all monitoring the same frequency of course.

I don’t recall how many miles of swamp passed beneath the wings before we finally achieved our cruise altitude of 3500’ but I do recall how flushed my face felt as I silently cursed myself for allowing this to happen. None of my group ever mentioned it to me, probably out of professional-courtesy. At least the rest of the group was professional...and courteous enough to just let it be.

Did it make a memorable event for me? You bet it did! In fact I was so mentally shook up thinking about it the rest of the day that is my only excuse for what happened on our return....

... because about the only thing that could possibly top that off.. was when I again led the gaggle on the return to ILM and were cleared to land on Rwy 24, and as I saw the pavement in front of us all neatly lined up about on 1/4-mile final....I FINALLY beginning to feel relieved the horrible day of my sorry-performance was about to successfully be ended.... Harold’s voice came over the tower fequency.... “George, you realize that you’re landing us on Runway ONE-SEVEN don’t you? .... 8O

N146YS: (expletive deleted)

ILM Tower: “Flight of Five, cleared to land on ANY runway!”

:oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops:
'53 B-model N146YS SN:25713
50th Anniversary of Flight Model. Winner-Best Original 170B, 100th Anniversary of Flight Convention.
An originality nut (mostly) for the right reasons. ;)
User avatar
cessna170bdriver
Posts: 4062
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 5:13 pm

Re: I thought I was overweight [aircraft]

Post by cessna170bdriver »

George, I was riding in one of the other airplanes (Jay Baeten), and until now I never realized it anything more than a same-way-same-day formation. :lol: :lol:
Miles

“I envy no man that knows more than myself, but pity them that know less.”
— Thomas Browne
User avatar
Joe Moilanen
Posts: 598
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2003 5:45 am

Re: I thought I was overweight [aircraft]

Post by Joe Moilanen »

gahorn wrote:It was with some degree of embarrassment when I realized what I’d done during the fly-out at the Wilmington convention in 2003. I was the “lead” aircraft of a 5-plane gaggle to take-off together from ILM to the Kill Devil Hills event, and for some reason I was “elected” to be the lead aircraft... perhaps because the rest of the gaggle was under the mis-impression I was paid at my regular job as a pilot so therefore I must be the “professional” in the group...therefore should lead. Not sure why they leapt to that deduction but their error was quickly proven ,,,and soon over-shadowed by my own.

I had planned Jamie and I to be alone in our B-model and we had been topped off with fuel two days earlier when we arrived in order to avoid any delays at the end of convention. I didn’t consider this two days later when Ol’ Gar (flyguy) approached me and asked if he and Deanna could ride-along on the flight up the Cape to the fly-out. So, as all 5 of us taxied into position and were cleared for take-off you might imagine my horror as I suddenly became aware of the lack of acceleration on that near 100-degree day.

To top that off, the No. 2 aircraft in the gaggle was Harold Holiman in his C-180... who was airborne in the first 500 feet... then the other three 170s who were airborne soon-after... while their brain-dead “leader” was still solidly on the pavement 1500-feet later and trying to accelerate.

The full fuel, 500 lbs of Ol’Gar and me sitting in front of another 250+ (To be kind to the ladies) sitting in the back-seats (not to mention the 40 lbs of survival gear and life-vests I always carried in the baggage on long trips) placed us at least 300 lbs over gross, and the only reason ol’ 146YS with it’s cruise-pitched-prop flew at-all that day was curvature-of-the-earth. .
Our departure instructions were to turn-right immediately after takeoff to a 050 heading, but while trying to gain sufficient speed to enable a climb out of ground-effect and with the stall warning occasionally squeaking I dared not initiate a turn. A mile off the departure end I called departure and got chewed-out for not being on assigned heading and I could only imagine what my followers were thinking of their elected-leader as we were all monitoring the same frequency of course.

I don’t recall how many miles of swamp passed beneath the wings before we finally achieved our cruise altitude of 3500’ but I do recall how flushed my face felt as I silently cursed myself for allowing this to happen. None of my group ever mentioned it to me, probably out of professional-courtesy. At least the rest of the group was professional...and courteous enough to just let it be.

Did it make a memorable event for me? You bet it did! In fact I was so mentally shook up thinking about it the rest of the day that is my only excuse for what happened on our return....

... because about the only thing that could possibly top that off.. was when I again led the gaggle on the return to ILM and were cleared to land on Rwy 24, and as I saw the pavement in front of us all neatly lined up about on 1/4-mile final....I FINALLY beginning to feel relieved the horrible day of my sorry-performance was about to successfully be ended.... Harold’s voice came over the tower fequency.... “George, you realize that you’re landing us on Runway ONE-SEVEN don’t you? .... 8O

N146YS: (expletive deleted)

ILM Tower: “Flight of Five, cleared to land on ANY runway!”

:oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops:
Reminds me of the time about 30 years ago (shortly after I got my 170) when I flew some friends to an outing in Sunriver OR. When it was time to depart with my 3 passengers on this hot afternoon, I topped of with fuel and departed the 5,000 MSL airport. My passengers were so impressed at how I circled around for the longest time so low that they could look at all the apples on the apple trees!! I didn't ever tell them that it wasn't on purpose...

Joe
4518C
User avatar
170C
Posts: 3182
Joined: Tue May 06, 2003 11:59 am

Re: I thought I was overweight [aircraft]

Post by 170C »

George, I wasn't in that particular 5 plane gaggle. I was in another one. Rumor had it you were elected to lead the group so as not to have any of the fast, green planes pass up your red one. That is just what the gossip was. :mrgreen:
OLE POKEY
170C
Director:
2012-2018
User avatar
GAHorn
Posts: 20989
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2002 8:45 pm

Re: I thought I was overweight [aircraft]

Post by GAHorn »

170C wrote:George, I wasn't in that particular 5 plane gaggle. I was in another one. Rumor had it you were elected to lead the group so as not to have any of the fast, green planes pass up your red one. That is just what the gossip was. :mrgreen:
It’s a damn good thing my airplane wasn’t GREEN or me and everyone onboard would have been killed off the departure end of the runway... the only saving grace being we’d at least have plenty of time to say our prayers before running off the end since it would have taken a green-theeng forever to get there... :mrgreen:
'53 B-model N146YS SN:25713
50th Anniversary of Flight Model. Winner-Best Original 170B, 100th Anniversary of Flight Convention.
An originality nut (mostly) for the right reasons. ;)
Post Reply