As it happens, this topic was discussed just a few weeks before my GE4522 gave up the ghost. Being frugal (to put it one way), I decided to give the Galaxy-brand 4522 from Aircraft Spruce and Specialty ("ASS") a try.
Well, the lamp arrived today, and I have to say I am disappointed. Although the back is stamped with the number "4522" and the words "Aircraft Landing Light," it is not identical to the GE-manufactured bulb that I am replacing. First, while the GE-brand lamp is flat on its face, the Galaxy-brand lamp has a concave face. More importantly, the filament shield is missing. As a result, when stowed the concave face of the lamp will extend below the surface of the left wing, and when deployed I will be without the benefit of the filament shield.
As noted in George's earlier post, the lamp was $13.90 from ASS, in contrast to $26.95 for the GE lamp from the same supplier. Postage to Alaska was a little more than $7. Even though I would prefer to have a flat faced lamp with the filament shield, I don't plan to send it back.
I think I may purchase a GE-brand 4522 sometime in the future when I can include it with a larger parts order, reducing the lamp's shipping cost significantly. At that point I'll place the Galaxy lamp in reserve status and not have to worry about being caught without an immediate replacement.
Looking on the bright side (no pun intended), because the Galaxy lamp has omitted the filament shield I don't have to worry about orientating the shield as debated in "Correct Orientation of 1948 Landing Light?."
http://www.cessna170.org/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=4069
However, a little research on the Cessna 120-140 website answered the shield-orientation question for me.
Neal Wright has posted a pdf file in which he discusses design and technical features of the Grimes swing-down landing light used in some C120s, C140s, and in the 1948 C170.
http://www.cessna120-140.org/forum/file ... s_2005.pdf
In the article, Mr. Wright indicates that he received information from someone who had acquired two never-used swing-down Grimes assemblies. Apparently, tags still glued to the lamp face stated:
"This light is supplied for installation in the left wing. The filament shield of the lamp is toward the pilot. To make this unit suitable for right wing installation merely rotate the sealed lamp 180 degrees."
Gordon Sandy
1948 C170
Juneau, AK