ORIGINAL vs. MODIFIED
Posted: Sun Oct 27, 2002 12:11 pm
"Modified" may mean different things in changing older airplane parts to enhance safety or operational ease. Changing from Goodyear wheels/ brakes to Cleveland wheels/ brakes is a very effective "up grade" and not really a modification.
Modifying the classic 170 by changing out the engine to one from a different mfg, larger size, different no. of cyls, a constant speed prop and a different exhaust systems is not the same level of modification at all. Owners, striving to enhance performance of their stock airplane by adding or changing to newer, better performing parts, while staying nearly "stock" won't be assessed many penalties if they enter a contest where authenticity is a consideration. Bet your money that a plane with Cleveland brakes and newer radios will be considered for awards over one with a Lycoming 180HP or a Continental IO360 210HP and C/S prop installed.
The owners of these "highly" modified airplanes are certain to be thrilled with the outstanding performance they feel is produced by those MODIFICATIONS, but if they fly alongside one, they will certainly notice that their "modified" C170 will not match the performance of a stock C180. The air speed limitation of the 170 is not increased to that of a 180. The payload is not increased to that of a 180 and the short field performance is not any better than that of a 180. Finally, the fuel consumption of the higher HP engines adds limitations to range and endurance unless the plane is "modified further" to carry more fuel. Carrying more fuel limits the payload in the cabin even more.
Different strokes for different folks.
Modifying the classic 170 by changing out the engine to one from a different mfg, larger size, different no. of cyls, a constant speed prop and a different exhaust systems is not the same level of modification at all. Owners, striving to enhance performance of their stock airplane by adding or changing to newer, better performing parts, while staying nearly "stock" won't be assessed many penalties if they enter a contest where authenticity is a consideration. Bet your money that a plane with Cleveland brakes and newer radios will be considered for awards over one with a Lycoming 180HP or a Continental IO360 210HP and C/S prop installed.
The owners of these "highly" modified airplanes are certain to be thrilled with the outstanding performance they feel is produced by those MODIFICATIONS, but if they fly alongside one, they will certainly notice that their "modified" C170 will not match the performance of a stock C180. The air speed limitation of the 170 is not increased to that of a 180. The payload is not increased to that of a 180 and the short field performance is not any better than that of a 180. Finally, the fuel consumption of the higher HP engines adds limitations to range and endurance unless the plane is "modified further" to carry more fuel. Carrying more fuel limits the payload in the cabin even more.
Different strokes for different folks.